OK so how about this.. it was mentioned back on the first page of this thread that we might like to keep the original ordering of the threads rather than sorting by last updated. That would cause problems for threads like this one (thread # 6) or the
Notable News thread (#26) because they would sit back on the last & second-to-last pages of threads even when updated.
So for the logged in users I could have two lists: all the "unseen" threads will be listed on the first page in order of last update. Then after that would be the master list of every thread in original posting order.
For someone who's not logged in I can show like the top ten most recently updated threads in the first list and then the master list.
This leaves one final gotcha: For threads like
Notable News Totally random videos the blow your mind thread and
i want one it seems like they can be posted to at any time to start a new sub-discussion about whatever the new post is. Once again you don't want to click through page after page of threads to find the right meta-thread to post your new thang. you could use the search feature but there should be a better way.
I see two solutions: sub-forums and sticky threads. sub-forums have been on the request list for a while now.. sticky threads would be the least disruptive to our current situation.
With either solution I'd probably apply it to the short list above and possibly a few others. Whatchoo think?
Edit:
Here's a page that lists all threads with > 1 page of posts.